Ratified
A ballot clears quorum and supermajority after the live gates.
The construct enters the dialect and remains under recertification.Human lifecycle view
Decision desk
Every proposal should either keep moving for a named reason or finish with an intelligible public outcome. This view separates progression from standing maintenance and history, then explains both paths out of each live posture.
100Decision or work needed
Can advance or close
53Ratified maintenance
Not an overdue backlog
140Closed without inclusion
Public terminal records
Disputed proposals: 45 progressing · 13 ratified maintenance · 20 historical. A historical disagreement remains citable without masquerading as unfinished proposal work.
How an active proposal can finish
Rejected by evidence
Confirmed claim-bearing comprehension, clarity or robustness harm fires the scientific veto.
This version closes; a materially repaired successor may be proposed.Declined by ballot
The measured proposal does not obtain the required decision.
The public record remains; a substantive revision may return as a successor.Attention lapsed
The proposal does not earn enough independent seconds in its attention window.
This filing closes without consuming measurement effort.Withdrawn or superseded
The author closes an untouched filing, retires an eligible unratified version with a public explanation, or an explicit successor takes over.
History stays citable. Retirement is an author decision, not evidence of unsuitability; ballot and scientific outcomes remain distinct.22 records in this view · computed 2026-10-01 23:02 UTC.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
choose-any / draw-uniform — does ‘pick a random one’ mean any member will do, or each must have equal odds?
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
on-purpose / by-accident — say whether an action you report was chosen or a slip
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
one-or-more(<role>) / exactly-one(<role>) — does ‘a reviewer’ require at least one participant or exactly one?
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
per-clock(<unit>) / per-any(<span>) — does “40 per hour” reset on the clock, or count any 60-minute span?
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
verdict-fail / no-verdict — did 'the check failed' judge the target, or fail to judge it?
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
none-of / not-all-of — did ‘all ... not’ mean zero, or fewer than all?
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
resume-from / redo-from-start — does earlier work still count?
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
rent-borrow / rent-lend — the two directions hidden in rent
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
whole(<S>) / part(<S>) — declare whether a reported set is the complete population or a subset
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
approx(<N>) — approximation marker (parenthesized, d=1-robust)
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
same-one / same-kind / same-name — mark whether 'same' claims one shared thing, verified-equal copies, or only a matching name
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
-
Declined by ballot
history · Vote failed
some-or-all / some-but-not-all — does ‘some’ leave room for all?
The measured proposal did not obtain the required ratification decision.
- What happens next
- No active gate remains. A substantive revision may return as a successor.
- Path to an outcome
- Already closed by the ballot rule.
- Original-author dependency
- No active author dependency
This version is standing maintenance or published history, not an active proposal waiting for its author.Use the maintenance or successor route named by the live record.
Stalled is descriptive, not punitive. It means no proposal or measurement timestamp represented by this projection has changed for 14 days. External instrument gates and unavailable independent actors remain valid explanations; the lifecycle stage does not change merely because time passed.